The Scale Is Lying to You:

How to Track Progress the Right Way
By
Theresa Straight
April 28, 2025
The Scale Is Lying to You:

Theresa Straight

   •    

April 28, 2025

If you've ever stepped on the scale, saw a number you didn’t like, and immediately felt defeated—you’re not alone.


We’ve been trained to believe that weight is the ultimate measure of success.


But here’s the truth: the scale is lying to you.

Weight is one tiny piece of a much bigger puzzle. And if you're only using the scale to judge your progress, you're missing all the real wins happening beneath the surface.

Let’s break it down:

Why the Scale Lies

1. Weight Fluctuates Naturally
Your body weight can swing 2-5 pounds (or more) daily based on things like:

  • Water retention
  • Sodium intake
  • Hormone cycles
  • Stress levels
  • Sleep quality
  • Digestion

None of that reflects fat gain or loss. Yet we panic when we see an extra pound on the scale after one "off" day.

2. Muscle Weighs More Than Fat
As you build muscle through strength training (which you should be doing!), the number on the scale may stay the same—or even increase.
But your body shape, strength, and metabolism are improving.
The scale can’t measure how strong you’ve gotten or how much healthier you are.

3. The Scale Doesn’t Measure Body Composition
There’s a huge difference between losing 5 pounds of water and losing 5 pounds of fat.
Or gaining 5 pounds of muscle versus gaining 5 pounds of fat.
The scale doesn’t tell you which is happening—it just shows a number.

How to Track Progress the Right Way

If the scale isn’t the answer, what is?
Here’s what to focus on instead:

✅ How Your Clothes Fit
Are your jeans looser? Are your shirts fitting better in the shoulders or waist? That’s body recomposition in action.

✅ Progress Photos
Take a photo once a month, same time of day, same clothes.
You’ll be shocked at the subtle (and not-so-subtle) changes you miss in the mirror every day.

✅ Strength Gains
Are you lifting heavier weights? Doing more reps? Mastering movements you couldn’t do before?
Strength is a huge marker of progress—and it’s way more meaningful than a lower number on the scale.

✅ Energy Levels
Are you less tired in the afternoons? Recovering faster? Feeling stronger during workouts?
Better energy = better health.

✅ Measurements
Tracking your waist, hips, thighs, arms, and chest can tell a very different (and often more exciting) story than the scale ever could.

✅ Sleep and Recovery
Better sleep patterns and quicker recovery times are signs that your body is getting healthier from the inside out.

Bottom Line: Progress Isn’t Just a Number

If you’ve been working hard and feeling frustrated by what you see on the scale, take a step back.
Look at the bigger picture.
Recognize all the ways you’re getting stronger, healthier, and more resilient—even if the scale isn’t budging.

The goal isn't to weigh less.
The goal is to live more.

And you are doing better than you think. 💪

Continue reading